Friday Food Finds – ProSupps MyCookie Review

Happy Friday friends! I’m a huge fan of the MyProtein Bars so I was anxious to try ProSupps MyCookie when it was released! I picked up three of the four flavors at my local Vitamin Shoppe. Today, I’m sharing my full review.

MyCookies are gluten free, contain zero trans fat or hydrogenated oils. MyCookie is a single serving, so no fear, just eat the whole darn cookie!


ProSupps MyCookie comes in four different flavors:

  • White Chip Chocolate
  • Peanut Butter
  • Snickerdoodle
  • Chocolate Chip

All of the cookies have a super soft texture and are not crumbly or floury like Lenny and Larry’s cookies can often be. All of the flavors also have a generous portion of icing on top of each cookie!

Without further ado, let’s jump into the review!

White Chip Chocolate

Loved the rich dark chocolate brownie-like density of this cookie! The flavor was somewhat reminiscent of a cookies and cream bar. Unfortunately, this one had a bitter protein/sweetener like aftertaste to it. There were also very few white chips in the cookie considering the cookie is aptly named White Chip. Macronutrients: 290 cals, 18g protein, 36g carbs and 8g fat. Overall rating: 7/10


Peanut Butter

If you’re a peanut butter lover like me, I’m pretty certain that you’ll love this cookie. Each bite was like a blast of peanut butter in my mouth – absolutely delicious! The peanut flavor reminded me slightly of the PB2 peanut flour. The Peanut Butter was my second favorite flavor. Macronutrients: 290 cals, 18g protein, 36g carbs and 8g fat. Overall rating:8/10.



Upon opening up the snickerdoodle cookie, I was immediately hit with a bakery-like cinnamon bun aroma! Packed with cinnamon flavor and bits of oatmeal and raisin, this cookie was absolutely heavenly. With the delicious base flavor of the cookie and the super soft consistency, this was my favorite! Macronutrients: 290 calories, 18g protein, 36g carbs and 7g fat. Overall rating: 9.5/10.

Awesome job on the cookies ProSupps! These are a great alternative to the Lenny and Larry’s cookies. Here is how I would rank the three flavors: Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter and White Chip Chocolate.

MyCookie is available for purchase at Vitamin Shoppe, and on the ProSupps website.

Follow ProSupps on their social media sites:




Have you tried ProSupps MyCookie yet? Which flavor would you choose? Please share – I would love to hear from you!

2 Responses to Friday Food Finds – ProSupps MyCookie Review

  1. Haven’t heard of these cookies before! They better amend the lack of white chocolate chips and the presence of an aftertaste, though. Too bad. On a more positive note, IT’S FRIDAY!!! Wishing you a stress-free, awesome weekend ahead. Can’t wait to catch up XO

    • Hey Liz! These cookies are definitely worth trying in my opinion! I agree, ProSupps needs to step up there white chocolate chip game! The snickerdoodle was definitely my favorite! Hope your week is off to a great start! XO

Wendy Moore
(610) 573-8494

© 2018 Moore Ways to Wellness     //       Privacy Policy     //       Terms of Use     //       Cookie Policy     //      Site Credits

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This